Observations on Peer Review

We asked our editors, reviewers, and authors to share their perspectives on peer review. You can see their responses by following the links below.

As a journal or book series editor, what do you see as the role of peer review?

What are the qualities of good peer-review feedback?

What approach do you take as you conduct a peer review?

As an author, what do you look for in the feedback provided through peer review?

As an author, what do you consider as you prepare a submission for peer review?

Additional Resources

We've also pulled together publications about peer review as well as resources offered by other publishers.

Understanding Peer Review: A Guide for Authors, by Taylor & Francis